
A FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLE of road racing made a huge difference in Jessica McClain’s gritty runner-up finish in the New York City Marathon.
The resurgent veteran seemed destined for no better than 4th during one stretch of the final miles in Central Park. But despite “not feeling amazing,” she was prepared for the grind and to fight back. Welcoming the undulating terrain, she closed on leaders Sheila Chepkirui — the defending champ — and Hellen Obiri. The American stunned onlookers as she simply navigated the twists and turns more efficiently than the defender, reeled her in and passed in the final strides. McClain’s runner-up finish (2:24:42) was the best for an American at NYC since Shalane Flanagan won in ’17.
And guess who she had to thank for that key strategic element?
“My high school coach, Jeff Messer, is the one to credit with the tangent running,” she laughs. “He drilled that into my brain as a 14-year-old. You know, run through the line, never look back, run the tangents, those were all things I learned in high school, and it’s just funny for them to come into play in a marathon on the global stage at 34. Clearly, he said it enough times for me to really store it back in the memory bank.”
That mental/muscle memory was a boost since McClain didn’t have her usual pep. “I didn’t feel as poppy as I did in Boston,” she says. “And Copenhagen [World Half-Marathon Champs] honestly took a lot out of me.
“I’ve learned that you really can’t judge the first 13–16 miles. You just don’t know how the race will unfold,” she adds. Her training, workouts incorporating a lot of gear shifting and callusing her legs to both uphill and downhill running, however, really paid off. “I was actually craving the Queensboro Bridge and a little bit more of the undulation that reflected my training more.
“It was also about how we talk to ourselves when things don’t feel perfect… just a lot of the little things I’ve been practicing along the way, all coming to a head.”
It was the latest in a string of rather stunning performances, even if sprinkled with a little heartbreak and adversity, by a 34-year-old 7-time Stanford All-American. After growing disillusioned with pro running, and having dealt with a multi-year series of injuries 2016–19, McClain “soft retired” from serious competition around the time the pandemic hit. (Continued below)
T&FN Flashback: 8½ years ago, McClain (then Jessica Tonn) hit a high note in what was a trying stretch of her career. In her first serious 10,000 at the ’18 Payton Jordan Invitational, she made herself the first U.S. 25-lap winner at that elite distance meet in 8 years. Read Jessica Tonn Tries The 10K here.
“I needed to grow up and I needed to gain just a larger world view, I think. Running can be a very selfish sport and I was just so caught up in my own career and my own injuries and just, you know, me, me, me. I needed to get a big-girl job and figure out who I was outside of running, because a lot of it was an identity crisis. I don’t think I knew who I was outside of the sport, and a lot of that was because I approached it with such an outcome/performance-oriented mindset versus truly enjoying the journey of it.
McClain became a fan of the sport again, then eventually the competitive itch started returning. “A marathon just sounded really fun for my 30th birthday,” she says. “It was a bucket list item, and I didn’t have a structure around me anymore, so I could do it my own way. It was fun to reenter the sport from just a play perspective, rather than mostly all work. I just needed a breather.”
So she “soft-returned” to run the Mesa Marathon in February ’22, notably stopping in a Dick’s Sporting Goods to buy shoes for the race the night before.
Imagine, she is asked, what she would have said if someone had approached her there and said, “Yes, you have been out of the sport awhile. But would you believe in the next 4 years you’re going to be nearly making the Olympic team, competing in World Championships and finishing 5th and 2nd in the Boston and New York marathons?
“Oh man, I would have said ‘No chance!’” she laughs. “I would’ve said, ‘You are crazy and you need to go get your brain checked out.’”
She won that downhill Mesa Marathon in 2:33:34, then tested the waters again the following year, finishing 4th at Grandma’s in 2:29:25. Then she stunned the U.S. running community at the ‘24 Olympic Trials in Orlando by coming within 15 seconds of making the Paris marathon team with 2:25:46.
She had planned the Trials to be her finale, hoping to just make the top 10. But now her performance begged the question, “What could transpire if she continued?”
How about track PRs at 5K (15:09.40) and 10K (30:59.71)? And all-time bests at almost every road distance, including 2:22:43 then 2:20:49 at Boston. Also selection to the’25 World Champs team in the marathon and an 8th-place finish in Tokyo. There’s also no forgetting the U.S. Championship Half-Marathon debacle where she was en route to victory, was led off course, then got to compete at the Worlds anyway and finished 7th.
And now, New York.
“I’ve kinda made a vow to myself that we’re only gonna do this as long as it’s fun. And, hopefully that lasts at least through March 2028 and then we’ll take it from there. But I’m having so much fun doing it, in maybe an unconventional way, but I think it’s resonated with people. I think there’s a lot of people out there who want to be able to know that they can do things and still have a family and have a job. And a pro runner used to look very much one way, and I think there’s so many different ways to do this now.”
McClain’s support“village” includes her husband and her coach, David Roche. Both are 100% on board with this new version of herself. Jessica Tonn married Connor McClain in November ’21, about 2 years after they met.
“Connor played sports most of his life,” she explains. “So he’s a competitor, but I think I met him during that hiatus that I was taking from racing, so I wasn’t really just the professional runner when we met, which was a good thing.
“He’s brought an element of fun to this… and he’s very focused on how we give back to the community that I’ve been a part of for so long. So I think it’s been a really cool mentality to operate in, where it’s like, ‘Hopefully I can do this at this level for another Olympic cycle if I want to. But at some point, I’ll be on the other side of professional running, and how do I want to take up space in the running world?’ He’s really good at helping me figure that out.
“And then my coach, David, is very much of a similar thread,” she continues. “I leave a lot of the training theory and science and data up to him. I don’t think about a ton of that. I just do what’s on paper, and then he tries really hard to just keep me operating in the same mindset that I’ve been operating in, which is really important.
“I think I’ve gotten to a point, too, where I’m just not overcooked,” she adds. “I run 70– 80M a week. I take a day off. I only have two hard efforts a week. I mean, I’m stacking a lot of steady quality miles. Then I get to races and I’m just really excited to try to hit that home run, whereas for a lot of workouts and practice, that’s meant for doubles and the occasional triple. But I get really excited to race, so I think that’s part of it, too.”
As for that “big girl job,” McClain has now served as the Executive Director of the LoveUp Foundation in Phoenix for nearly 4 years, an opportunity that manifested shortly after she became the marketing manager for the organization’s sister non-profit, the Scottsdale-based #LovePup Foundation. The former focuses on helping children in foster care and granting community wishes, while the latter is involved with rescuing, rehabilitating, and rehoming dogs.
After New York, she returned home to organize and, ultimately, emcee The #LovePup Family Fest in Mesa, which drew more than 8000 people for a massive, large-scale adoption event and featured Grammy nominated singer-songwriter Gavin DeGraw.
“I get to wear a marketing hat, logistics hat, event-planning hat. So it’s very fun, and I feel like the work that we’re doing is making a difference, which has always been important to me. This work keeps the bumpers up for me, and keeps me in check, which I think is a good thing.”
McClain admits that in the past, she used to continuously be threatened by other people’s success. “That’s a very hard thing to say out loud. When you’re operating in that fear mentality mindset or the scarcity mindset, it’s so hard to enjoy anything you’re doing. But when you’re lifting other people up and you’re a part of the wave, it’s so much more fun. I’m trying to figure out how to be that person.”