Facts, Not Fiction

 
Page 1 of 4 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 31
  1. Collapse Details
    Briana Williams as gAOY choice
    #1
    I have been a fan of the Track and Field News magazine ever since I first became involved with high school girls track and field as a coach. So for about 4 decades I have been heading to the newsstand or my mailbox and now the "webernet" to see who ran a top time or won a championship. But the one issue in my time as a reader and subscriber that I have always looked forward to the most is the All America Team/Athlete of the Year issue. This year was a little different as we didn't get a full representation of the female high school awards as we all had to wait for the Briana Williams positive drug test at the Jamaica World Championships qualifying meet to be adjudicated. With Ms. Williams handlers and lawyers having adequately put up a defense that exonerated her, T&FN decided to give the female athlete of the year award to Briana.

    Here is where I am a little disappointed as I had hoped that an athlete I have some association with would win and get the recognition she so richly deserved as she continued to rewrite the high school record book in the female heptathlon. Yet she had to settle for second place and the month long wait to have her hopes dashed. I am not complaining about the process or the actions of people who although I have seen in person wouldn't know me from "Adam", or the opinion of people who oversee this website and magazine as it is their responsibility to the bottom line and to provide content that will keep readers such as myself coming back.

    What I am disappointed in is the air of confusion and dramatic results around an award that should have none of those things. Who wins an arbitrary award based on the opinion of a group of writers is always going to be subjective and also what opinion the person reading the article has about who won. But here I am a little confused as to what constitutes the criteria for this award? Briana Williams while attending and participating in track and field meets and competitions in the United States still represents her native country Jamaica in any international competitions. Also having court proceedings delay the presentation of an award will draw controversy to that award not to mention the fact that those court proceedings were again held in another country, about a race in that country where the athlete in question failed a drug test. No matter the reason for Briana Williams acquittal and exoneration how is this relative to an United States of America award. If this were a world wide award, which it isn't, I would fully understand the delay. So one has to wonder is the intent to add controversy and drama to an already arbitrary and subjective process?
    Reply With Quote
     

  2. Collapse Details
     
    #2
    Quote Originally Posted by eman2001 View Post
    But here I am a little confused as to what constitutes the criteria for this award? Briana Williams while attending and participating in track and field meets and competitions in the United States still represents her native country Jamaica in any international competitions.
    So did Mondo Duplantis.
    Reply With Quote
     

  3. Collapse Details
     
    #3
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    right where I'm supposed to be.
    Posts
    629
    Difference being Mondo also represented his high school, having competed not only at regionals and state, but in multiple events as well.
    Reply With Quote
     

  4. Collapse Details
     
    #4
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Madison, WI
    Posts
    23,482
    Quote Originally Posted by highjumpfan View Post
    Difference being Mondo also represented his high school, having competed not only at regionals and state, but in multiple events as well.
    But Mondo was in a different situation, with his family having a long history linked to Louisiana and school.

    As for Williams, she had a AAF; I do not think that she failed a drug test. There is a difference and it is important. Note that if she were not competing there for Jamaica (and instead went the Junior route?) I think that this would not have arisen and I doubt that the Post 86 would have been written, even though the basic complaint, representing Jamaica would have been the same. Clearly, some of those involved with making the decision on AOY wanted to see what would happen, so the delay was understandable and almost inevitable.
    Reply With Quote
     

  5. Collapse Details
     
    #5
    Quote Originally Posted by 26mi235 View Post
    But Mondo was in a different situation, with his family having a long history linked to Louisiana and school.

    As for Williams, she had a AAF; I do not think that she failed a drug test. There is a difference and it is important. Note that if she were not competing there for Jamaica (and instead went the Junior route?) I think that this would not have arisen and I doubt that the Post 86 would have been written, even though the basic complaint, representing Jamaica would have been the same. Clearly, some of those involved with making the decision on AOY wanted to see what would happen, so the delay was understandable and almost inevitable.
    There were 85 posts before I chimed in on this matter so the thread which reads "Jamaican Sprinter Alleged Failed Test" wasn't a minor issue when it happened. My post was on the delay on making a decision about who the girls high school "AOY". T&FN didn't make a decision at the time that it usually did even though they did so for the boys high school "AOY" but waited until a decision could be made on why there was a positive reading on Briana Willaims drug test "A" and "B" samples. I further point out that the incident in question happened while she was competing to become a member of the Jamaican National team in Jamaica that was to be sent to the IAAF Track and Field World Championships. So T&FN was waiting why a another country was making a decision about an athlete that was trying to make that countries national team to decide on who the American girls high school"AOY" was to be.

    That's the slippery slope that T&FN found themselves on because had they made Briana Williams the "AOY" before the matter was cleared up and she had not been cleared of the positive reading then they would've had to explain to everyone why they gave the award to someone who had turned up with a positive result on a drug screening.

    My point being why open yourself up for criticism at all which at this moment I am free to do so as a citizen of the United States and a member and subscriber of this web-page and bulletin board. Also in future postings that I make to any thread on this board I would like to not be told that I shouldn't be able to express my opinion. I am not trolling or being inflammatory just expressing an opinion that I had formulated using my 35 years of experiences while coaching track and field as a reference.
    Reply With Quote
     

  6. Collapse Details
     
    #6
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    Right next to a Gator filled pond
    Posts
    4,822
    Had Ms. Williams chosen to compete as a US athlete, made the team and had the same potential violation arise leading to whatever the legal process would be taking its course under the same timeframe, would it have been a problem?
    Reply With Quote
     

  7. Collapse Details
     
    #7
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Madison, WI
    Posts
    23,482
    So we should anoint an AAOY, Almost Athlete of the Year. Since she has NO Peds issue (now) what is your point, anyone that has the possibility of a Doping violation should not be getting such an honor. I suspect very few of those on the top 10 list were tested much, ...
    Reply With Quote
     

  8. Collapse Details
     
    #8
    Quote Originally Posted by NotDutra5 View Post
    Had Ms. Williams chosen to compete as a US athlete, made the team and had the same potential violation arise leading to whatever the legal process would be taking its course under the same timeframe, would it have been a problem?
    But that is not what happened and using a hypothetical situation brings in other factors that don't necessarily apply to this situation.

    I am in no way trying to disparage Ms. Williams character nor am a casting aspersions about her performance. I've personally been in attendance at 5 track meets where she has competed on an absolute stellar level and find her to be a marvelous track and field athlete and one of the potential future stars of the sport and I have no problem with her being named the girls high school athlete of the year.

    The problem I have is with the process of delaying the naming of the girls high school athlete of the year and the circumstances which caused it.

    The good people at the Track and Field News publication company were handed a bag of lemons, they did there best to make lemonade. Still doesn't take away from the fact that they had to add sugar and water to get to a desirable outcome.
    Reply With Quote
     

  9. Collapse Details
     
    #9
    Yes, there was a delay, but can you tell us what great harm resulted from that delay?
    Reply With Quote
     

  10. Collapse Details
     
    #10
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    Right next to a Gator filled pond
    Posts
    4,822
    Quote Originally Posted by eman2001 View Post
    But that is not what happened and using a hypothetical situation brings in other factors that don't necessarily apply to this situation.

    I am in no way trying to disparage Ms. Williams character nor am a casting aspersions about her performance. I've personally been in attendance at 5 track meets where she has competed on an absolute stellar level and find her to be a marvelous track and field athlete and one of the potential future stars of the sport and I have no problem with her being named the girls high school athlete of the year.

    The problem I have is with the process of delaying the naming of the girls high school athlete of the year and the circumstances which caused it.

    The good people at the Track and Field News publication company were handed a bag of lemons, they did there best to make lemonade. Still doesn't take away from the fact that they had to add sugar and water to get to a desirable outcome.
    ....and your solution?
    Reply With Quote
     

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •